Top Jewelry Stores

Why St. John & Myers Stands Out Among Lexington’s Top Jewelry Stores

When it comes to procuring fine, classic jewelry in Lexington, few names carry more weight than St. John & Myers. This compact workshop boutique, located at 198 Moore Drive, is much more than a jewelry store; it's a haven for individuals who appreciate craftsmanship, history, and custom artistry. 

St. John & Myers is one of the best jewelers in Lexington KY, and combines passion and skill in a way that few others in the area can. Whether you are looking for a vintage Art Deco engagement ring, a cherished restoration for a family heirloom, or a custom statement piece, this boutique stands apart.

Reasons Why St. John & Myers Stands Out Among Lexington’s Top Jewelers

Whether you're in the market for an original engagement ring or a lovingly restored family heirloom, St. John & Myers brings a level of passion, authenticity, and quality rarely seen in the Lexington jewelry market. Here are a few reasons they remain a unique choice for the jewelry buyer in you.

1.      A Legacy Rooted in Antique & Period Expertise

St. John & Myers is the best jewelers in Lexington KY, with an authority on antique and period jewelry, including Art Deco, Art Nouveau, and Edwardian items, in Central Kentucky. We do not carry generic jewelry designs like a big box retailer; we are boutique and hand-pick actual estate jewelry from throughout the world, each with its unique history, craftsmanship, and character.

2.     Custom Design Meets Certified Gemology

Visit our in-house gemologist with many years of experience in appraisal and custom design. The team marries certified loose diamonds and precious metals into unique individualized jewelry of art that can be described using terms such as one-off, only, and never to be duplicated.  The St. John & Myers team's vast experience is evident when sourcing or restoring rare settings and unique gemstones.

3.     An Uncommon Selection of Rare Pieces

This jeweler's gallery features unusual and rare jewelry, specifically color-change sapphires, filigree wedding bands, and period-correct engagement ring things you just won't find at chain stores in Lexington.  They deal with a lot of antique and estate pieces, so the actual inventory changes every week. That constantly-changing mix is part of the reason that St. John & Myers deserves the title of the best jewelers in Lexington KY.

4.     Personalized, Educated Service

St. John & Myers may be smaller than a big-box jeweler, but that's intentional. We guide you every step of the way, whether scheduling a visit, reviewing the vintage ring options, or customizing the designs.

The reviews indicate that St. John & Myers  goes  above and beyond. One customer in Salt Lake City shared that the day before Valentine's Day, they received an email with ring options and presentation instructions, arriving just in time.

5.     Rare Brands, Estate Pieces & Designer Collaborations

Suppose you have a preference for signed goods. In that case, St. John & Myers has a rotating selection of estate jewelry from heralded names such as Tiffany & Co., Cartier, Bulgari, Georg Jensen, David Andersen, and others. We are the largest antique jewelers in Lexington KY, offering a choice of collectible cufflinks and stick pins, along with rare and period accessories, catering to both collectors and individuals seeking meticulously curated items.

 Being one of only three independent retailers from Kentucky invited into Preferred Jewelers International provides another form of prestige, showing a commitment to excellence on a national scale.

6.      Better Value Through Curated Selection

St. John & Myers sources carefully and keeps their overhead low, making fabulous quality estate jewelry available at wholesale pricing. With their turning collection, you are likely to find pieces that seem special and thoughtfully priced often. This rare trifecta of authenticity, quality, and value gets them consistently mentioned among the best jewelers in Lexington KY.

7.      Wedding & Engagement Jewelry Expertise

If you’re searching for an engagement ring, wedding band, or anniversary gift, there’s no other store offering this level of specialization. Their selection of period engagement rings turns over weekly, with certified diamonds and unique vintage settings. They offer ring resizing, restyling, appraisal, and financing/payment options, all in a boutique, client-oriented atmosphere.

Final Thoughts

If you want a jewelry experience that goes beyond the usual understanding, St. John & Myers stands out among the excellent options available in the Lexington jewelry scene. Our skills in antique jewelry, attention to detail, and focus on the customer experience place us among the best jewelers in Lexington KY

Whether you are intrigued by the romance of vintage design, the aesthetic of a careful restoration, or if you seek jewelry that is a truly custom creation, St. John & Myers provides a unique experience with grace, integrity, and skill.

Back to blog